Research, Publications & Media
We provide a hub for scholarship that explores how ideas and practices associated with ‘brainwashing’ have intersected with Cold War controversies about the psy sciences of psychology, psychiatry and psychoanalysis.
Battles of the mind: The long Cold War
The term ‘brainwash’ was coined in 1950 amidst Western concern that Communist states were indoctrinating their captives during the Korean War. In this strand of the project, we explore the origins and novelties of ideas of brainwashing, and we map their connection to clinicians’ analyses and therapeutic treatment of prisoners of war. We look closely at the scientific expertise that was mobilised – by various governments and non-government organisations around the world – to produce new psycho-technologies for influencing the attitudes and behaviours of political subjects.
Shadows of colonialism
This strand of our research assesses the extent to which imperial powers used psychological concepts and expertise in counter-insurgency, propaganda and re-education programmes after 1945. Existing histories reveal a great deal about the brutality of prisoner treatment, but less about the specialised, psychologically-attuned strategies taken to win ‘hearts and minds’ through forms of emotional coercion and surveillance. Our project reviews the nature of advice and information proffered by psychological specialists in the context of, for example, American psychological warfare in the Philippines, French action psychologique in Algeria, and British counter-insurgency operations in Malaya, Cyprus and Kenya.
Advertising, film and hidden persuasion
Cold War cinema and television depicted brainwashing’s myriad dangers while also being cast in their own right as forms of covert pacification and normalization. Meanwhile, social scientists offered compelling accounts of the psychology and politics of advertising, and the predicament of the consumer and the voter when bombarded with signs and messages. Vance Packard’s The Hidden Persuaders (1957) famously warned of the redirection of clinical and therapeutic ideas to fashion desires and anxieties through seductive imagery and well-chosen words. Our research investigates post-war critiques of these dark arts and cultural representations of the mind in an age of ‘hidden persuasion’.
‘Psy’ expertise: Debates, reflections, reckonings
During the Cold War the reputation of psychology, psychiatry and psychoanalysis underwent complex transformations. Our project asks how debates about tyranny and totalitarianism shaped theories of the psyche, and vice versa; it considers how and why revelations and allegations of brainwashing returned to haunt all of the psy professions. Here we also examine the key writers and movements that emerged to challenge the psy sciences and investigate how brainwashing fears were taken up in ‘anti-psychiatry’ movements.
Shaping the Child’s Mind
The enormous human loss and displacement brought about by the Second World War caused many children to grow up without mothers and fathers within institutions, substitute families, or cultures radically different from their own. This provided the ‘psy’ professions with the rare opportunity to observe the development of infants in vivo. How do notions of thought control, autonomy and freedom change when we consider not only the psychology of adults, but of children and adolescents – and with what effects for pedagogy, parenting, mental health or therapy? We examine how questions of nurture rather than nature became vitally important after 1945, as societies began to construct a moral vision for a new generation of Cold War babies. We also explore the legacies of these debates for visions of the self, and for child psychiatry and psychotherapy today.
Here and now
Cold War-era concerns about, and fascination with, mind control continue to resonate. We ask how images, techniques and fears of brainwashing have shaped present-day practices and attitudes. How do postwar debates about brainwashing inform contemporary commerce, culture, politics and the psy sciences? We explore the psychiatric treatment and cultural representation of prisoners of war, the role of clinicians in so-called ‘enhanced interrogation’, and ideas of indoctrination, suggestion, subliminal persuasion, and political ‘re-education’ that still draw upon – or take their distance from – these Cold War concerns.
Publications and Media
The list below comprises the films produced, interviews conducted, and work written (or co-written) by members of the research team.
Our website also contains dozens of blogs edited by the research team and written by associates of the project (see Blogs)
Books and Theses
- Brainwashed: A New History of Thought Control. Daniel Pick. (Wellcome Collection/Profile, forthcoming 2022)
- The Captured Mind: Race, Brainwashing, and American Film (1941-53). Ian Magor, PhD thesis. Birkbeck College, University of London 2020
- Battles for the Mind: Brainwashing, Altered States and the Politics of the Nervous System (1945-1970). Charlie Williams, PhD thesis. Birkbeck College, University of London 2017
- Psychoanalysis in the Age of Totalitarianism. Matt ffytche and Daniel Pick (eds) (Routledge, 2016)
- Psychoanalysis: A Very Short Introduction. Daniel Pick (Oxford University Press, 2015)
Digital Series
- The Hidden Persuaders (2019) – a 6-part digital series on brainwashing, mind control and the ‘psy’ professions – The Wellcome Collection
Articles
-
Hidden persuaders on film: Exploring young people’s lived experience through visual essays (2021). Research for All, 5 (2), 383–99. Daniel Pick, Mary-Clare Hallsworth and Sarah Marks.
- Homosexuality, Created Bodies and Queer Fantasies in a Nigerian Deliverance Church. Journal of Religion in Africa (November 2021) Naomi Richman
- Rene Spitz’s Empty Frames: ‘‘Hospitalism’, ‘Screen Analysis’ and the Birth of Infant Psychiatry. Psychoanalysis and History (forthcoming 2022) Katie Joice
- Narrating the Infant: a new look at the films of James and Joyce Robertson’. Psychoanalysis and History (forthcoming 2022) Katie Joice
- Review of Gavin Miller, Miracles of Healing: Psychotherapy and Religion in Twentieth-Century Scotland. Psychoanalysis and History (April 2021) Naomi Richman
- Machine gun prayer: The politics of embodied desire in Pentecostal worship Journal of Contemporary Religion (December 2020) Naomi Richman
- Mothering in the frame: Cinematic microanalysis and the pathogenic mother, 1945–67 History of the Human Sciences (October 2020) Katie Joice
- ‘Mothering in the Frame’ – an interview with Katie Joice History of the Human Sciences Online (September 2020) Katie Joice in discussion with Hannah Proctor
- Nigerian Pentecostalism Database of Religious History (August 2020) Naomi Richman
- At Play at the Wellcome History Workshop Online (December 2019) Katie Joice
- On ‘modified human agents’: John Lilly and the paranoid style in American neuroscience History of the Human Sciences (October 2019) Charlie Williams
- Review of Jacqueline Rose, Mothers: An Essay on Love and Cruelty Psychoanalysis and History (April 2019) Katie Joice
- Voices off: Stanley Milgram’s “Cyranoids” in historical context History of the Human Sciences (March 2019) Marcia Holmes and Daniel Pick
- Psychotherapy in Europe History of the Human Sciences (December 2018) Sarah Marks
- Suggestion, Persuasion and Work: Psychotherapies in Communist Europe European Journal of Psychotherapy & Counselling (January 2018) Sarah Marks
- Thinking About Denial History Workshop Journal (August 2017) Catherine Hall and Daniel Pick
- The Romani Minority, Coercive Sterilizations, and Languages of Denial in the Czech Lands History Workshop Journal (August 2017) Sarah Marks
- Brainwashing the cybernetic spectator: The Ipcress File, 1960s cinematic spectacle and the sciences of mind History of the Human Sciences (July 2017) Marcia Holmes
- Psychotherapy in Historical Perspective History of the Human Sciences (April 2017) Sarah Marks
- Radicalization: Lessons on Mind Control from the 1950s (February 2017) Sarah Marks and Daniel Pick ( first published in The World Today, the magazine of Chatham House) www.theworldtoday.org
- Brainwash Culture History Workshop Online (March 2016) Katie Joice and Ian Magor
Journal Special Issues
- Psychotherapy in Europe History of the Human Sciences (2018) ed. Sarah Marks
- Denial in History History Workshop Journal (2017) ed. Felix Driver, Catherine Hall and Daniel Pick
- Psychotherapy in Historical Perspective History of the Human Sciences (2017) ed. Sarah Marks
Contributions to Books
- ‘Reconstructing Pinky’. Wild Analysis: From the Couch to Cultural and Political Life, ed. Shaul Bar-Haim, Elizabeth Sarah Coles and Helen Tyson, Routledge (2021) Ian Magor
- Preface, Wild Analysis: From the Couch to Cultural and Political Life, Routledge (2021) Daniel Pick and Jacqueline Rose
- ‘Deliverance Ministries: History, Theology and Practice’. Handbook of Megachurch Studies, Routledge (forthcoming 2023) Naomi Richman
- ‘Using Film in the History of Psychiatry’. Sources in the History of Psychiatry, from 1800 to the Present, Routledge (forthcoming 2021) Katie Joice
- ‘Hidden in Plain Sight: Uncovering the Secret History of Brainwashing – a Dialogue’ Ian Christie and Daniel Pick in Where is History Today? New Ways of Representing the Past (ed. M. Arbeit and I. Christie, 2015)
Films
- Rites Undone (2021) Directed by Naomi Richman
- Three Films About Mass Influence (2021) Directed by Lily Ford
- Re-reading Fanon (2021) Directed by Nasheed Qamar Faruqi
- Mothering in the Frame (2021) Directed by Katie Joice and Ian Magor
- Chasing the Revolution: Marie Langer, Psychoanalysis and Society (2021) Directed by Lily Ford
- Hidden Persuaders School Outreach Project (2020) A Jarman Lab production
- Nothing Exists Until You Sell It (2019) Directed by Bartek Dziadosz
- Every Man has his Breaking Point (2017) Directed by Phil Tinline
- David Hawkins: A Battle for the Mind (2017) Nasheed Qamar Faruqi [shortlisted for the AHRC Best Research Film of the Year 2017]
- Richard Sennett interviewed by Daniel Pick (2017)
- Prof. Tim Shallice on ‘interrogation in depth’ and sensory deprivation (2016) Marcia Holmes
- Workshop on Interrogations (2016) Marcia Holmes
- Zygmunt Bauman interviewed by Daniel Pick (2016)
- The Voice of America (2016) Ian Magor
- Too Much Momma (2015) Ian Magor
- Getting at ‘em Early (2015) Ian Magor
- Interview with Robert J. Lifton (2014) Daniel Pick
- Monica Kim interviewed by Marcia Holmes, Charlie Williams and Daniel Pick (2014)
Radio, Podcasts & Lectures
- ‘Psychotic States Revisited: Reflections on Psychoanalysis, History, and Paranoia in the Age of the Virus’ New Center for Psychoanalysis in Los Angeles (August 2020) Daniel Pick
- ‘A Psychoanalyst Studies Brainwashing Fears’ IPA Off the Couch Podcast (October 2019) Interview with Daniel Pick
- ‘D for Diagnosis: What’s in a Name’ BBC Radio 4 (July 2019) ft. Sarah Marks
- ‘Free Thinking: Are We Being Manipulated?’ BBC Radio 3 (December 2018) ft. Sarah Marks
- ‘Free Associations? Psychoanalytic History, Democracy and the State We Are In’ British Psychoanalytic Council’s Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy Now Conference, November 2017, Daniel Pick
- ‘The Unconscious Life of Bombs‘ BBC Radio 4 (December 2017) Presented by Daniel Pick
- ‘Freud for our Times’ BBC Radio 4 (January 2017) Presented by Daniel Pick
- ‘Dictators on the Couch‘ BBC Radio 4 (June 2017) Presented by Daniel Pick, ft. Sarah Marks
- ‘Brainwash Culture’ BBC Radio 3 (13 March 2016) Presented by Daniel Pick, ft. Marcia Holmes
- ‘On the History of Sensory Deprivation and the Counterculture’ Float Conference (February 2017) Presented by Charlie Williams
- Introducing Psychoanalysis Oxford University Press (August 2015) Presented by Daniel Pick
- ‘The Roots of Extremism’, BBC Radio 4 (March 2014) Presented by Daniel Pick
Blog Posts
- Rites Undone: Director’s statement (August 2021) Naomi Richman
- Voyage to Leros: Histories of multi-layered confinement on a Greek Island (August 2021) Danae Karydaki
- On re-reading 1984 (July 2021) James Brown
- A Cultural History of the Brain in the 1950s (June 2021) Andreas Killen
- The Market Enchanters: Mind Control in the History of Advertising (May 2021) Anat Rosenberg
- Chasing Marie Langer: A film by Lily Ford (April 2021) Lily Ford
- The Pathology of Boredom (February 2021) Lizzie Burns
- On Attentive Listening With Tanya Luhrmann (September 2020) Interviewed by Naomi Richman
- Narratives of Apocalypse (April 2020) Naomi Richman
- A Faceless Crisis (April 2020) Naomi Richman
- Do Good Enough Mothers Make Good Enough Democracy (March 2019) Charlie Williams, Sarah Marks, and Daniel Pick
- Solitude and Sensory Deprivation (and Johnny Cash) (February 2019) Charlie Williams
- Psychotherapy Across the Atlantic (December 2018) Sarah Marks and Rachael Rosner, History of the Human Sciences Blog
- The British Way in Brainwashing (November 2017) Marcia Holmes, History of the Human Sciences Blog
- On UFOs and the Cold War Human Sciences: An Interview with Greg Eghigian (November 2017) Sarah Marks
- On the Unexamined Presence of Psychotherapeutics: An Interview with Sarah Marks History of the Human Sciences Blog (May 2017)
- Brainwashing in Communist Czechoslovakia – And After (September 2017) Sarah Marks
- Institutional Psychotherapy in France: An Interview with Camille Robcis (September 2017) Katie Joice
- Across the Iron Curtain (May 2017) Sarah Marks
- Edward Hunter and the Origins of ‘Brainwashing’ (May 2017) Marcia Holmes
- Albert Mason on the Medicine and Magic of Hypnotism (July 2016) Marcia Holmes
- Reviewing Laing’s ‘Asylum’ in the Age of Neuroscience (November 2015) Katie Joice
- What We’re Reading Now: The APA Report (July 2015) Marcia Holmes
- ‘The Cold War and the Hidden Persuaders’ (June 2015) British Psychoanalytic Council Blog, Daniel Pick
Useful External Links & Resources
- HEAD-Geneva’s Radical Experiments in Art and Psychology
- Demons of the Mind – on the Psy Sciences and Cinema in the Sixties
- The CIA’s Freedom of Information Reading Room
- CENSAMM – Centre for the Critical Study of Apocalyptic and Millenarian Movements
- INFORM – Centre on Cults and Brainwashing, linked to the LSE
- Archived website on conspiracy theories from CRASSH
- Cold War Conversations Podcast series
- Catalogue from the exhibition, ‘War of Nerves: Psychological Landscapes of the Cold War’ at the Wende Museum
- “Solitudes” Research project on the health-related aspects of solitude in Britain, from the 17th century to present day, based at Queen Mary
- Birkbeck Centre for Interdisciplinary Research on Mental Health
- Centres for Victims of Torture